25+ Father’s Day Gift Ideas

Check out our 25+ Father’s Day Gift Ideas list below. We’ve also created a few gift combinations and gift basket ideas for you.

Would you like to create a custom foodie gift basket for Dad? Give us a call 908-852-9122 x1 or send an email with your request.

Gift Combinations & Gift Basket Ideas

  • Grillmaster & BBQ Gift Combo – Select prime meat cuts from The Meat Shoppe at Arctic Foods, Bone Suckin’ BBQ Sauce, Lancaster Sweet Chili Sauce, Lancaster Jalapeno Ketchup and Pilsudski Dill Mustard w/ Horseradish
  • Some Like it Hot Gift Combo – Donaldson Farms Hot Salsa, Pilsuski Sriracha Gourmet Mustard, DiBruno Bros. Cheddar Horseradish Cheese Spread, Kilhaney’s Fire Eater Pickles, Stoltfuz Smoked Kielbasa w/ Spicy Cheese Snack Sticks, and DiBruno Bros. Spiced Nut Mix
  • Say Cheese Gift Combo – Springhouse Dairy flavored Cheese Curds, DiBruno Bros. Gourmet Cheese Spread, Raw Aged Green Tree Cheddar, and Fresh Mozzarella.

Sauces & Salsa

  • Donaldson Farms Tomato Sauce – made with our own tomatoes, onions, and peppers
  • Donaldson Farms Salsa – made with our own tomatoes and other ingredients and available in mild, medium and hot
  • Lancaster Jalapeno Ketchup, Bacon Ketchup, Sweet Chili Sauce, Raspberry Chipotle
  • McCutcheon’s Happy Mouth BBQ Sauce & Apple Butter BBQ Sauce
  • Bone Suckin’ Sauce – HOT

Pickles & Pickled Items

  • Kilhaney’s (local!) Garlic Dillicious, Apple Pie Pickles, Not Your Average Bread & Butter Pickles, Fire Eater Pickles, Freaky Tiki Pickles, Beetnicks Pickled Beets,
  • McCutcheon’s Three Pepper Medley, Sweet Corn Relish, Sweet Pepper Relish, Sweet Fire, Sweet Pickle Relish, Hot Chow Chow & Beet Balls

Local Cheese & Dips

  • Assorted Raw Milk Cheese from Klein Dairy (Easton, PA)
  • Assorted Farm Cheese from Springhouse Creamery (Fredon, NJ)
  • Assorted Flavored Cheese Curds from Springhouse Creamery (Fredon, NJ)
  • Fresh local Mozzarella Cheese
  • Assorted Raw Aged Cheese from Green Tree Farm
  • DiBruno Bros. Gourmet Cheese Spreads/Dips available in Port Wine, Cheddar & Horseradish, Pinot Grigio & Fig, Smoked Gouda & Beer, Roasted Garlic & Herb, and Gorgonzola

Meats Cuts & Cured Meats

  • Prime meat cuts and steaks from The Meat Shoppe at Arctic Foods
  • Cured Meats – salami, sopressata
  • Flavored Meat Snack Sticks
  • BACON! (enough said)
  • Stoltzfus Ring Bologna