Christmas and Holiday Pies

Order fresh-baked, delicious pies for your Christmas, Hanukkah and winter holidays! Our Farm Market offers over 30 fresh-baked pie varieties including no-sugar-added pies. Pie Prices range from $12.99 – $14.99 (Just Made Bakery Gluten Free and Mince Meat Pies $18).

Online pie orders must be placed by Noon on Tuesday, December 18th. You may still call or stop by our farm market to place your pie order.  After Dec. 18th we will continue to keep our pie shelves filled and accept pie orders through our market closing on Christmas Eve day at Noon. Order your pies now by calling our Farm Market 908-852-9122 x1.

While our market offers over 30 varieties of pies we do not bake all varieties every day. If you are interested in a specific pie variety, please call our Farm Market to find out if it’s available or place your order ahead and we’ll have it ready for you!

We’ve simplified your holiday for you this year – order your prime rib, turkey, pies, ahead and have them ready for you when you pick up your veggies, breads, milk, cheese and more at our farm market – as fresh as it gets! You’ll have more time for relaxing with family, friends and maybe a little football, too!

Holiday Pie Dates & Times: December 22nd, 23rd (9am – 6pm) and before noon on Christmas Eve. 

Call our farm market at 908-852-9122 x1 or visit our Farm Market to place your order

We’re now taking orders for Christmas, Hanukkah, New Year’s Eve and winter holiday fresh locally-raised turkey Piedmontese prime rib and pies!  Did you know you can order a fresh (not frozen), cage-free, all-natural turkey raised without hormones, steroids and antibiotics from Donaldson Farms?

Need a few uniquely thoughtful holiday gift ideas? Check out our online Holiday Gift Guide!

Christmas, Hanukkah & Winter Holiday Pies & Desserts

Fresh-baked Pie Varieties 9″
Apple Crisp
Apple Pie
Apple Berry Delight
Apple Raspberry
Apple Walnut
Dutch Blueberry
Lemon Blueberry
Black Cherry
Cherry Crumb
Cherry Vanilla
Chocolate Chip Pecan
Coconut Custard
Lemon Blueberry
Mango Strawberry
Mince Meat (by Just Made Bakery) – Wednesday, November 21st
Peach Blueberry
Peach Crumble
Peach Melba
Peach Praline
Pineapple Upside Down
Strawberry Rhubarb
Sweet Potato Crunch
Very Berry

No Sugar Pie Varieties
Apple No Sugar
Blueberry No Sugar
Cherry No Sugar

Other Desserts
Dessert Shells
Angel Food Rings
Half Cakes
Crumb Cakes
Loaf Cakes
and more!

Christmas, Hanukkah and winter holiday pie orders can be ordered by calling our Farm Market 908-852-9122 x1

Online ordering has ended for the season. You can still call us to place an order!